Menu of Guerriero Gelato & Cakes in Caldwell, New Jersey, USA

Menu Overview

Guerriero Gelato & Cakes, nestled on Bloomfield Ave in Caldwell, NJ, is a shining gem in the world of artisanal frozen desserts. This ice cream shop masterfully balances tradition with innovation, crafting flavors that aren’t just tasted—they are experienced. With a story rooted in passion and resilience, founder Mike Guerriero’s journey from sweeping floors to creating award-winning gelato is as inspiring as the luscious treats they serve.

The menu is a celebration of quality and creativity. Standouts like the Cannoli and Blueberry Mint flavors defy expectations, blending fresh, vibrant ingredients into gelato that feels both familiar and refreshingly unique. The Coffee Gelato pays homage to classic Italian flavors with a rich, bold espresso base that lingers elegantly on the palate. Mint lovers will find pure joy in the Mint Chip, which combines creamy gelato with chocolate bits for a perfect, cooling bite. Not to be overlooked, the Chocolate Covered Strawberry Ice Cream offers a luxurious balance of sweet fruit and decadent chocolate, a true indulgence.

The award-winning gelato doesn’t stop at individual scoops. Their lineup of ice cream cakes is thoughtfully crafted—like the Baci Cake, which comes in Hazelnut and Chocolate Hazelnut, its smooth flavors complemented by tasteful decoration matching each variety. For those with allergies, the Stock Cake caters to nut-free needs with a classic vanilla and chocolate combo layered with fudge and crunchies, customizable in appearance but consistent in flavor. The Oreo Cake delivers a nostalgic twist, perfect for celebrations and satisfying Oreo addicts.

Guerriero Gelato & Cakes also shines through its diverse serving options: from single cups of their signature homemade hard ice cream to the uniquely layered “Build Your Own Breezy,” where soft serve meets a symphony of toppings in a shake cup. The Italian Ice, available in pints, quarts, and cups, offers refreshing fruit-forward choices, while their Granita blends soft serve and Italian ice, creating a delightful texture and flavor contrast that’s rare to find.

Dessert lovers will be particularly charmed by the Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie and the Mint Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie. These pies combine housemade brownie bases, lush layers of fudge, and ooey-gooey ice cream, topped with whipped cream, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle—a decadent, multi-layered treat that echoes the shop’s attention to detail and love for rich, satisfying flavors.

Customer feedback underscores the exceptional quality and community spirit of Guerriero Gelato & Cakes. From Tami Jean’s delight in their sugar-free coffee chip gelato to Michael Vargas’ heartfelt praise of the shop’s immaculate cleanliness and heartfelt craftsmanship, the consensus is clear: every scoop is made with care. The uniquely balanced Blueberry Basil and the boldly textured Espresso Chip are consistently noted highlights, reflecting not just top-tier ingredients but also true artistry.

Beyond the gelato itself, the team at Guerriero Gelato & Cakes delivers an experience marked by warmth and professionalism. Community members like Redline Youth commend the brand’s commitment to local outreach, while Sarah’s experience highlights their accommodating, friendly service and a welcoming ambiance that makes visiting a pleasure. Their ability to rise to occasion—such as catering school graduations with flexibility and kindness—emphasizes their dedication to customer satisfaction and quality.

In every scoop and slice, Guerriero Gelato & Cakes offers a harmonious blend of tradition, innovation, and heartfelt craftsmanship. Whether you’re drawn by the award-winning gelato, the creative cake options, or the community spirit woven through every interaction, this shop in Caldwell is not just a destination—it’s a celebration of flavor, culture, and passion. If you’re anywhere nearby, do yourself a favor: indulge in their thoughtfully curated menu and taste the heart they pour into every creation.